Skripsi
PERTIMBANGAN HAKIM DALAM MENJATUHKAN PUTUSAN TERHADAP ANAK YANG BERBEDA DENGAN REKOMENDASI PENELITIAN KEMASYARAKATAN OLEH PEMBIMBING KEMASYARAKATAN
Judges are required to take into account social inquiry reports prior to rendering decisions in juvenile cases. However, in practice, judges may issue decisions that differ from the recommendations set forth in such reports. This study aims to analyze the urgency of social inquiry reports as a basis for judicial consideration, the factors underlying the discrepancy between judicial decisions and the recommendations of social inquiry reports, as well as the ideal concept of social inquiry reports as a foundation for judicial reasoning. This research uses a normative-empirical legal method, using statutory, case-based, and futurist approaches. The findings indicate that social inquiry reports hold significant importance as a non-juridical basis for judges in comprehensively assessing the condition of the child. Differences between judicial decisions and the recommendations of social inquiry reports are influenced by discrepancies between facts revealed during trial and those presented in the reports, differing perspectives between judges and probation officers in assessing the effectiveness of sanctions and the best interests of the child, as well as the application of the principles of judicial independence and discretion in decision-making. Furthermore, efforts are required to address the weaknesses of social inquiry reports, substantively, normatively, and juridically in a simultaneous manner in order to establish an ideal framework for such reports as a sound basis for judicial consideration. Keywords: Judicial Consideration, Judgment, Children in Conflict with the Law, Social Inquiry Report, Probation Officer
No other version available