Skripsi
RATIO DECIDENDI HAKIM DALAM MENJATUHKAN PIDANA TERHADAP PELAKU TINDAK PIDANA MERINTANGI KEGIATAN PERTAMBANGAN (STUDI PUTUSAN KASASI NOMOR 5690 K/PID.SUS/2025)
ABSTRACT The purpose of this study is to identify and analyze the judges' considerations in Cassation Decision Number 5690 K/PID.SUS/2025 concerning the imposition of sanctions for the criminal offense of obstructing mining activities, as well as to examine the types of sanctions that should be applied to such offenses in the future. This research employs a descriptive-analytical method aimed at systematically describing and explaining the research issues through a normative approach, encompassing statutory regulations, court decisions, and relevant legal concepts. The findings indicate that Cassation Decision Number 5690 K/PID. SUS/2025 regarding the criminal offense of obstructing mining activities, as regulated under Article 162 of the Mining Law, reflects the Supreme Court's effort to balance law enforcement in order to ensure investment certainty while simultaneously upholding substantive justice. The cassation judges consistently applied criminal law provisions to acts of obstruction that were proven, while also taking into account non-juridical aspects such as agrarian conflicts and social impacts in determining the sanctions. Consequently, the decision rendered is proportional and does not disregard the public sense of justice. Looking forward, the application of sanctions for this offense is expected to be oriented toward a more progressive and restorative criminal law policy, not solely emphasizing custodial sentences such as imprisonment, but also incorporating multidimensional forms of sanctions, such as substantial fines or obligations to undertake environmental restoration. Such an approach is intended to maintain a balance between the protection of investment interests and community rights, while also encouraging synergy among law enforcement institutions to achieve effectiveness, proportionality, and the ultimate goal of safeguarding a sustainable mining sector. Keywords: Ratio Decidendi, Mining Crime, Cassation Decision
No other version available