Skripsi
MODEL PENGELOLAAN LINGKUNGAN SUMBER DAYA AIR DI DAERAH IRIGASI KELINGI TUGUMULYO
This study examines the environmental management of Water Resources in the Irrigation Area of Kelingi Tugumulyo, which is transforming an agricultural irrigation system into a multi-user system between rice paddy farming and heavy water pond fish farming. This change triggers pressure on irrigation systems, especially in the form of water utilization conflicts caused by distribution imbalances, increased water demand, high network water loss, low return flow, and weak socio-institutional aspects such as supervision, compliance, and trust between users. Conflicts that occur are not solely caused by the physical limitations of water, but are the result of a complex interaction between hydrological-infrastructural, production-economic, and socio institutional factors that influence each other in a dynamic system. This study aims to analyze the dynamics of conflict, identify key factors that influence it, and build a System Dynamics model that is able to represent the cause-and-effect relationships in water management as a whole. With a mixed methods approach, the study combines qualitative analysis to understand community behavior and institutions, as well as quantitative analysis to measure water availability, productivity, and system performance. The developed Model integrates three main subsystems, namely hydrology-infrastructure, production-economy, and socio-Institutional, with key variables such as water availability, water demand, water loss, return flow, productivity, income, conflict, compliance, and trust. The results showed that water utilization conflicts are systemic and are formed through a feedback loop mechanism that tends to worsen the condition (reinforcing loop), where water deficit increases conflict, conflict decreases compliance, and low compliance further increases the irregularity of water intake. The main factors affecting the conflict include the efficiency of irrigation networks, the availability of effective water, the return flow from fish ponds, the distribution of economic benefits, the effectiveness of supervision and enforcement of rules, the level of compliance, and social trust. The System Dynamics Model has been validated and proven to be able to describe the behavior of the system and is used to evaluate various policy alternatives. The simulation results showed that a single policy was not effective enough in resolving conflicts, while the combinative policy scenario that includes network rehabilitation, strengthening supervision and enforcement, and increasing return flow became the most optimal alternative. This scenario can improve network efficiency, rice and fish productivity, and revenue, while significantly reducing conflicts and increasing compliance and trust between users. This finding confirms that multi-user irrigation management should be conducted through an integrated approach that integrates technical and institutional aspects simultaneously. Theoretically, this study makes an important contribution by developing a dynamic systems approach that locates conflict, compliance, and trust as endogenous variables in water management systems. In practical terms, the resulting model can be used as a decision support tool to design policies that are more adaptive, measurable, and sustainable. The main recommendation of this study is that first the management of water conflicts should be done through a combinative policy that integrates infrastructure improvements, institutional strengthening, and efficient water flow management; second, the regulation of water utilization permits for fish farming needs to be prioritized and followed by consistent and fair supervision and enforcement of rules; third, rehabilitation of irrigation networks should be focused on reducing water loss, especially in areas prone to water shortages such as downstream areas; fourth, optimization of return flow from fish ponds needs to be encouraged in order to create synergies between the agricultural and fisheries sectors; fifth, the establishment and strengthening of multi stakeholder collaborative institutions is needed to improve coordination, trust, and compliance; the seven resulting system Dynamics models need to be further developed as data-driven policy tools; and the eight further studies are recommended to include additional variables such as climate change, water retention, and land use dynamics to strengthen the accuracy of the models. Overall, this study confirms that the success of Water Resources Management in multi-user irrigation systems depends not only on the physical availability of water, but also on the quality of governance, user behavior, and policy integration that is able to answer the dynamics of the system as a whole and sustainably. Keywords: Water Resources Management, Water Conflict , System Dynamics